Here’s what keeps executives awake at night: You’ve got a brilliant strategy. Your board loves it. Your investors are excited. Your team is energized.
Yet, deep down, you know there’s a chance it’s going to fail.
Not because the strategy is wrong. Not because your people aren’t talented. But because somewhere between the boardroom presentation and the daily grind of execution, things fall apart.
The statistics haven’t budged in decades: 60-90 percent of strategies still fail in execution. Your strategy looks perfect on paper and holds big promises, but it’s not translating into results. The real challenge isn’t crafting better strategies—it’s transforming those strategies into action.
The Trapped Strategy Problem
Today’s business environment is unforgiving. Organizations are simultaneously managing supply chain disruption, talent wars, technology acceleration, and economic pressure to do more with less. The strategies addressing these challenges are often sophisticated and well-reasoned.
But here’s the problem: Those beautifully crafted strategies become trapped the moment they hit organizational reality. Departmental silos emerge. Teams focus on their individual goals rather than collective progress. People understand the pretty end goals but lack clarity on what drives day-to-day progress toward those outcomes.
The execution? That’s where things get messy.
The Four Questions That Determine Success
After studying strategy execution across hundreds of organizations, we’ve found that success or failure hinges on how well leaders can answer four fundamental questions:
- “Do people really understand what we’re trying to accomplish?"
This sounds obvious, but it’s where most strategies start to unravel. Your executive summary makes perfect sense to the leadership team. But three levels down, does a regional manager understand how their daily decisions connect to the strategic vision? Can they explain the “why” behind the changes you’re asking them to make?
In a fast-moving environment, clarity becomes even more critical. When people are juggling multiple priorities and fighting daily issues, they need crystal clear direction about what matters most and why. - “Do people have the capability to execute what we're asking?”
Strategy documents love to assume capabilities that don’t exist. “We’ll leverage data analytics to improve decision-making.” Great—but can your middle managers analyze data, or are they still making decisions based on instincts and last month’s reports?
The capability question isn’t just about training. It’s about whether people have the knowledge, skills, experience, and confidence to do what the strategy requires. In an era where job requirements are rapidly evolving, this gap is widening. - “Do our systems and processes support what we’re trying to do?”
You want faster decision-making, but your approval processes require seven signatures. You want better collaboration, but your teams use incompatible systems. You want innovation, but your budgeting process punishes experimentation.
The brutal truth is that most strategies require changes to how work gets done, but organizations underestimate the friction created by existing systems, processes, and organizational structures. - “Are we actually rewarding the behaviors we say we want?”
This is where execution fails. Leadership announces a new strategic direction, then continues to reward the old behaviors. You say customer focus is paramount, but your performance reviews still emphasize short-term sales numbers. You preach collaboration, but promote the biggest individual contributors.
People pay attention to what gets measured, recognized, and rewarded, not what gets announced in town halls.
The Three Execution Killers
Most execution failures stem from three predictable patterns:
- Everything becomes a priority. When supply chain, sustainability, cost reduction, and growth are all labeled “strategic,” nothing gets the focused attention needed to succeed.
- Departments optimize for themselves. Marketing hits their goals, operations hit theirs, finance hits theirs—but collective progress toward strategic objectives stalls because no one owns the connections between functions.
- Reality doesn’t match the plan. Strategies assume normal staffing and budgets, but execution happens with stretched teams, departed key players, and constrained resources.
Making Strategy Execution Work
The honest assessment? Most organizations are trying to execute too many strategies simultaneously while under-investing in the fundamentals that make execution possible. The key is streamlining execution by focusing on what drives progress.
- Start with ruthless prioritization
Before worrying about execution excellence, get crystal clear about what you’re trying to execute. If everything is a priority, nothing is. Make the hard choices about what gets resources, attention, and time.
- Break down departmental barriers
Stop allowing teams to optimize for their individual metrics while ignoring collective outcomes. Create shared accountability for strategic results that forces cross-functional collaboration.
- Focus on progress drivers, not just end goals
Don’t just communicate the vision—identify and track the specific behaviors, decisions, and actions that move you toward strategic objectives. People need to understand what drives progress, not just what success looks like.
- Invest in understanding, not just communication
Don’t just announce your strategy—test whether people understand it. Can they explain how their role connects to broader objectives? Do they know what success looks like? Can they make trade-off decisions aligned with strategic priorities?
- Build capabilities before you need them
Stop assuming people can learn complex new skills while also hitting current performance targets. Invest in building capabilities gradually and systematically and with realistic timelines.
- Align your reinforcement systems
Honestly look at what your organization rewards. Do your performance metrics, recognition programs, and promotion criteria support your strategic direction, or do they reinforce old behaviors?
- Design for real-world constraints
Plan your execution assuming budget cuts, key departures, and competing priorities. Build strategies robust enough to survive contact with organizational reality.
The Bottom Line
Strategy execution hasn’t become harder because business is more complex—though it is. It’s harder because the gap between what strategies assume and what organizations can deliver has widened.
The leaders who succeed will be those who honestly confront this gap. They’ll invest as much energy in building execution capabilities as they do in crafting clever strategies. They’ll make difficult choices about priorities instead of trying to do everything at once. They’ll tear down the departmental barriers that keep teams focused on individual goals rather than collective progress.
Most importantly, they’ll remember that strategies don’t execute themselves. People do. And people need clarity, capability, support, and motivation to turn strategic intentions into business results.
The question isn’t whether your strategy is brilliant. The question is whether you’ve created the conditions for brilliant execution.
Conversation